How Far Would You Go For An Autograph? The Hobby’s Future Is At Stake

Conning Carlton for a
free autograph?

I’ve never been good at footnotes.

My aging memory seems to recall a tale (or urban legend?) in which non-signing Steve Carlton was asked for an autograph by a young man in a wheelchair. Carlton’s teammates urged him to sign.

He agreed, only to watch the fan leap from the wheelchair, laughing at the deception.

If true, I’d claim such duplicity wouldn’t be as bad as deceiving someone with a written autograph request. (Unless someone produces incriminating Youtube footage…)

Think about it. Whether by e-mail or by U.S. Mail, there’s a trail of evidence. One shady letter could be the smoking gun that a reluctant autograph giver would need to shut down the giving (or set up a stiff fee schedule for signatures).

This scam from 2011 wasn’t limited to baseball autographs. However, the ramifications of future fiascos could cause an organized pushback against collectors. Don’t bend the truth about subscribing to a Tigers newsletter, being an admiring little kid or any other tale you can’t back up. With the Internet, former players could Google our behinds as fast as we research them.

2 thoughts on “How Far Would You Go For An Autograph? The Hobby’s Future Is At Stake”

  1. That’s a shame! I got Carlton via TTM and sent him a check to his charity. Simple enough. It doesn’t surprise me that someone would do something like this, though. It’s the world we live in these days.

  2. I think the tale (which I might have gotten from one of those BASEBALL DIGEST fillers years back?) revolved around an ACTIVE Lefty. Getting Carlton to sign during his career? Good luck!


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: